The Protestant Reformation: What It Was, Causes and Consequences

The Protestant Reformation was a sixteenth-century movement of church renewal that, beginning with Martin Luther’s 95 Theses in 1517, ended up dividing Western Christendom. This guide explains its causes, its leaders and its consequences.

By the myTheodemy TeamUpdated:

What the Protestant Reformation was

The Protestant Reformation was a movement of religious renewal that shook Europe in the sixteenth century. It began as a call for the Western church to return to what the Scriptures teach, and it ended with the division of Western Christendom into several traditions: Roman Catholic, Lutheran, Reformed and others that emerged later.

Its leaders did not see themselves as founding new churches. They saw themselves as reformers of the church that already existed. The questions at stake were theological: how a person receives God’s forgiveness, what authority the Bible holds, and what place the church and its sacraments have.

The name “Protestants” dates from 1529, when Lutheran princes and cities protested at the Diet of Speyer against a decision that held back the progress of the reform. In time, the word came to describe all the churches that grew out of this movement.

In one sentence

The Reformation was a sixteenth-century movement that called for a return to the Bible as the final authority and to God’s forgiveness as a gift, and it left Europe with several churches instead of one.

Timeline

The Reformation at a glance

  1. 1517

    The 95 Theses

    On October 31, in Wittenberg, Luther makes public his disputation on indulgences.

  2. 1521

    The Diet of Worms

    Luther refuses to retract before Charles V, and the Edict of Worms declares him an outlaw.

  3. 1529

    The name “Protestants” is born

    Lutheran princes and cities protest at the Diet of Speyer.

  4. 1534

    The complete Bible in German

    Luther’s complete Bible appears, twelve years after his New Testament of 1522.

  5. 1545–1563

    The Council of Trent

    The Catholic Church defines the doctrines that had been questioned and corrects practical abuses.

  6. 1555

    The Peace of Augsburg

    Each prince of the Empire may choose between Catholicism and Lutheranism for his territory.

  7. 1648

    The Peace of Westphalia

    A long era of religious wars in Europe comes to an end.

The dates in this timeline are explained in more detail in the sections that follow.

Background and causes of the Reformation

The Reformation did not come out of nowhere. For centuries, voices had called for change, and in the early sixteenth century religious, cultural and political factors came together to let that call spread.

Earlier voices

The English theologian John Wycliffe, who died in 1384, argued that the Bible should be within reach of the people and that Scripture was the final authority. The Bohemian preacher Jan Hus shared some of those ideas and was executed in 1415, condemned by the Council of Constance. His death left a deep mark on Bohemia and was remembered for generations.

The printing press and a return to the sources

Around 1450, Johannes Gutenberg developed movable-type printing. For the first time, a text could be copied quickly and cheaply, and pamphlets, sermons and translations circulated as never before. At the same time, humanism encouraged the study of the original languages and of ancient writings. Scholars went back to the Greek text of the New Testament, which made it possible to compare the practice of the church with what the earliest documents said.

Indulgences

An indulgence was, in the teaching of the time, the remission of a temporal penalty for sin, granted by the church. Over the years, its preaching became tangled up with money, and many believers understood it as a way of buying forgiveness. That practice was the immediate trigger of Luther’s protest.

Political factors

In the Holy Roman Empire, German princes sought more autonomy from the emperor and the papacy. Some saw the reform as a chance to strengthen their power; others embraced it out of conviction. Both motives were mixed together, which is why the story of the Reformation is both religious and political.

Martin Luther and the 95 Theses

Martin Luther was born in 1483 in Eisleben and died in 1546. He was an Augustinian monk and a professor of Bible at the University of Wittenberg. Luther was troubled by the question of how a sinner can stand before a holy God, and his study of the Scriptures gave him an answer that changed his life.

That answer came above all from his reading of Romans 1:17: the righteousness God offers is not a prize to be earned but a gift received by faith. This idea, justification by faith, became the heart of his message. You can see how it is summarized in the guide to the five solas of the Reformation.

What the 95 Theses were

On October 31, 1517, in Wittenberg, Luther made public the 95 Theses, known by their usual title: “Disputation on the Power and Efficacy of Indulgences.” The trigger was the preaching of indulgences by Johann Tetzel, tied to the financing of St. Peter’s Basilica.

The theses were not a manifesto for founding a church. They were an invitation to an academic debate, written in Latin and typical of the university setting of the day. They questioned the use of indulgences and reminded readers that a believer’s repentance is an attitude for the whole of life.

According to tradition, Luther posted the text on the door of the castle church in Wittenberg. Historians debate that detail. What is certain is that on that day he sent the theses to Archbishop Albert of Mainz. Thanks to the printing press, copies and translations spread across Germany within weeks, and what was meant to be a debate among scholars became a public matter.

From Worms to the German Bible (1520–1534)

Rome responded firmly. In 1520, Pope Leo X issued the bull “Exsurge Domine,” which demanded that Luther retract several of his claims. Luther refused, and on January 3, 1521, he was excommunicated by the bull “Decet Romanum Pontificem.”

In April 1521, Luther appeared before the Diet of Worms, in front of Emperor Charles V. He was asked to retract his books, and he refused, arguing that his conscience was bound to the Word of God. In May 1521, the Edict of Worms declared him an outlaw, that is, outside the protection of the law.

Frederick the Wise, Elector of Saxony, kept him safe by hiding him in Wartburg Castle. There Luther took on a work of enormous reach: translating the New Testament into German. It was published in September 1522, and his complete Bible in German appeared in 1534.

The translation had a double effect. It put Scripture in the hands of people who had never been able to read it in their own language, and it helped shape written German. From then on, translating the Bible would be a distinguishing mark of the churches of the Reformation.

The Reformation spreads across Europe

Luther was the most visible face, but not the only one. The Reformation had several centers, each with its own emphases and, at times, disagreements with the others.

Zurich
Huldrych Zwingli began preaching there in 1519 and launched a reform that followed Scripture very strictly. In 1529, at the Marburg Colloquy, he and Luther could not agree on the Lord’s Supper.
Anabaptists
In 1525, the first adult believers were baptized in Zurich, marking the start of the Anabaptist movement. They held that faith must be personal and that the church is a community of believers. For that reason they were persecuted by Catholics and by other reformers.
Lutherans
In 1530 the Augsburg Confession was presented, written by Philip Melanchthon. It became the founding document of the Lutheran churches.
Geneva
In 1536 the first edition of John Calvin’s “Institutes of the Christian Religion” appeared, a work associated with Geneva that shaped the Reformed and Presbyterian churches.
England
In 1526, William Tyndale’s English New Testament was published. In 1534, the Act of Supremacy made King Henry VIII head of the Church of England, the source of the Anglican tradition.
Scotland
In 1560, the Scottish Parliament adopted the Reformed faith, with John Knox as its leading figure.

These branches agreed on the authority of Scripture and on salvation by grace, but they differed on matters such as the Lord’s Supper, baptism and church government. Many of those differences are still alive among evangelical churches today.

Flashcards

Reformers and movements: who was who?

The Reformation and the Bible in Spanish

The Reformation also left its mark on the Spanish-speaking world. In 1569, the Bear Bible (Biblia del Oso), a translation by Casiodoro de Reina, was published in Basel. It was the first complete translation of the Bible into Spanish made from the original languages.

In 1602, Cipriano de Valera revised and republished it. That is the origin of the Reina-Valera tradition, which is still the basis of many Spanish Bibles read in evangelical churches today.

The Catholic response and the consequences

The Catholic Church responded with the Council of Trent, which met from 1545 to 1563. It defined with precision the Catholic doctrines the reformers had questioned and corrected practical abuses. This process is called the Counter-Reformation or the Catholic Reformation, depending on the historian’s emphasis.

Religious conflicts mixed with political ones and brought war. The Peace of Augsburg in 1555 recognized that each prince of the Empire could choose between Catholicism and Lutheranism for his territory. The Peace of Westphalia in 1648 ended a long era of religious wars in Europe.

A lasting legacy

  • The Bible in the language of the people. Translations allowed believers to read Scripture for themselves.
  • The priesthood of all believers. Drawing on texts such as 1 Peter 2:9, the reformers taught that every Christian has direct access to God and a calling before Him.
  • Education and literacy. Reading the Bible pushed communities to open schools and teach more people to read.
  • A plurality of churches. The institutional unity of the West was broken, and over time the Lutheran, Reformed, Anglican, Baptist, Methodist and Pentecostal traditions emerged.

Historians and churches weigh these outcomes differently. Catholics and Protestants agree, however, that that century changed the history of Christianity forever.

How to keep studying the Reformation

The Reformation is best understood with a guide that combines history and theology. You can browse the courses on church history and see how the centuries before and after 1517 connect.

If you would rather start at no cost, there is a selection of free courses. And to get into the movement’s central ideas, read the guides to Luther’s 95 Theses and the five solas of the Reformation.

myTheodemy is an online theology course platform with evangelical teachers from different traditions. Each one teaches from their own perspective, so you can get to know the Reformation from several angles.

Test yourself

How much do you remember about the Reformation?

Question 1 of 4

In what year did Luther make the 95 Theses public in Wittenberg?

Frequently asked questions

What was the Protestant Reformation in a nutshell?
It was a sixteenth-century movement of religious renewal that called for a return to the authority of the Bible and to salvation as a gift of God. It began with Martin Luther in Germany, spread across Europe and ended up dividing Western Christendom into several traditions, including the Lutheran, Reformed and Anglican.
When did the Protestant Reformation begin?
Its start is usually dated to October 31, 1517, when Martin Luther made his 95 Theses on indulgences public in Wittenberg. There were earlier precedents, such as Wycliffe and Hus, and other centers of reform, such as Zwingli in Zurich from 1519, but that date is the most widely used reference point.
What role did the 95 Theses play in the Reformation?
They were the spark. They questioned the practice and preaching of indulgences, which many understood as a way of buying forgiveness. Luther reminded readers that a believer’s repentance lasts a whole lifetime and that forgiveness is a gift of God. They were an invitation to an academic debate, not a plan to found a new church.
Why is Reformation Day celebrated on October 31?
Because October 31, 1517, is remembered as the day Luther sent his 95 Theses from Wittenberg to Archbishop Albert of Mainz. According to tradition, he posted them that day on the door of the castle church, although historians debate that detail. Many Protestant churches commemorate the day.

Keep studying

More guides

Protestant Reformation: Causes and Legacy | myTheodemy